| « Awayday - Fratton Park | MANCHESTER CITY LEAD THE WAY IN CUTTING PRICES » |
Hughes' style, mediocrity or magic?
I personally wasn't very happy when Sparky was given a job at City at the end of last season. Having seen Blackburn play on numerous occasions at Ewood park (not against City) I thought his side there to be very average and had certainly over- achieved.
Hughes had a method for success which was apparently modelled on the current Blackburn manager Allardyce's time at notloB. Much has been made of Blackburn's physical nature. Labelled by Wenger violent, Blackburn became a constant feature at the bottom end of the Fair-Play league. It wasn't pleasant to watch. A half empty stadium despite Blackburn having reasonable success attested to that. It did make them a difficult side to beat, however and teams feared going to Ewood.
Sir Taggart of Fergiestan had some interesting remarks about Blackburn and the man himself, Mark Hughes. Apart from calling them "dirrty" which wasn't well received, he highlighted that Blackburn were well organised and their game plan was based on being fitter than the opposition, working the ball in the corners and chasing down teams for 90 mins. A tactic of heavy defence, utilised notoriously by the poorer sides of Seria A to combat the big rich sides in the league.
Hughes' dogmatic approach has led to his conviction that his coaching staff from Wales and Blackburn are the best in the league and his "football factory" training regime will quite simply produce a better player. He is arrogant regarding his staff considering he has actually achieved very little in his management career. He embraced the physical side to the game with a series of low grade fouls throughout the 90 mins which is able to frustrate and wear down the opposition. At the expense of creative players, a reliance on the hearty, "full of gusto" workman and the big physical player.
Hughes has implemented his same dogmatic regime at city, a team that has been for years a side based on attacking flair and good football. From Keegan's complete disregard for defending to Sven’s patient continental style of absorbing pressure and breaking with technically gifted players. Hughes new regime has become as a complete culture shock. His desire for workmen has stifled and restricted the flair players. We have seen at the start of the season, city winning by large margins in one game, losing in the next. A confused side that when allowed to express it self, looked impressive, but inconsistent over the 90 mins. Hughes clearly disapproved of Sven's regime and style of play and these creative outbursts have slowly been eradicated. In place is a functionality. The signings he has made generally support his style of play apart from Jo and Robinho who of course where signings from the owners. Now he has spent his vast sums of money on players like Bellamy, suited to a midtable club. Our last performance at home to Boro was a signal of more too come. We lacked tempo an creative flair. We were functional and organised. A general negative approach, the desire to grind out a win at the expense of attacking flair.
Steven Ireland has been lauded as somewhat of a genius this season, but I have some reservations about his entire ability. He lacks vision and quality in his final third. His energy and work rate will win over fans who believe these types of players fight for the club.
The likes of Elano and Jo haven't really been given a chance this season. Jo has moved on and instantly became a success at a club that consistently finished above us in the league. He did the role Hughes has been asking for all season. Hughes persistence in trying to sign the vastly over rated Santa Cruz showed poor judgment and a lack of belief in a player that he didn’t want to bring to the club. It undermined Jo's role at the club and left him disheartened and shook his confidence. He has been unfairly labelled a misfit, lazy and it seems odd that he can walk into a more successful side and put in a performance of a tall target man, who is both footed and can score goals. 6 starts, is that really fair? It's clear Hughes never really wanted him.
Elano has played exceptionally well whilst Ireland was suspended, and even on his poor recent form, Elano still cant get into the side. Elano too has been a victim of plenty abuse this season from city fans. Last seasons hero, he started this season the same, but was dropped after scoring two goals. He doesn't suit Hughes style, he doesn't run up and down the pitch for 90 mins puffing an wheezing, he is creative attacker who needs protection.
Something has to be said about the man himself. He has constantly reminded us this season that his door is always open. He is always been a difficult character his frosty relationships with certain managers including his old boss Taggart highlights this. The red face champion boozer has described Hughes as an introverted and difficult character. Elano stated early in the season players don't feel able to approach Hughes if they have a problem. I think his character is part of the problem that he hasn't been able to mould the technically gifted foreigners and the workers into a unit. His single minded vision meant he has alienated those who don't suit his style.
We have a squad capable of much more than it's currently achieving and you have to ask why Hughes has failed to get the best out of these players. He has brought in some decent players which you would expect when you spend over a 100 million on a team. I don't want to watch a team who play percentage football, are simply workman like and very negative. I don't think it will last, unless results and performances improve very quickly.
In conclusion,I don't think his transfer targets, footballing style or aims have changed since his time at Blackburn. He has simply moved a inflexible model to a bigger club and it doesn't fit with players, the desire for good football of the fans and most importantly the owners who want City to be a shining example for Middle East influence in the west.
by NEWS OF THE BLUES
Trackback address for this post
Trackback URL (right click and copy shortcut/link location)
32 comments
I don't agree. We needed to get functional and organised, then use the flair players we have.
Clean sheets are the first requirement. Look at them over the road. Hughes has addressed this and its working.
Stevie Ireland has been the outstanding player of the season. He is class. His anticipation is first class, he has vision, can pass and and score. You must be watching another player. Ah that's it you got mixed up with that waster Robinho....
Sven had some good results last season (Mainly 1-0 seria A stuff)The football this year has been mostly superior.Hughes has now realised that he needs to grind out some victories just as Sven did the first half of last season.
I don't know if Hughes will turn us into a top 4 side but he should be given a couple of seasons and I don't think he will be far off.
I have a season card and to be honest have enjoyed more of the games this season than last. Do agree though that from now until the end of the season will tell us a lot but we seem to be in reasonable shape
It'll build a good base for future seasons, and over time Hughes will learn to adopt more creative approaches to his footballers, and let them work their magic, it would be suicide to do it this season, we beat one team 3-0 then lose the next match and thats because he was using the idea that attack is the best form of defence.
Give me 1-0 wins any day if it moves us up the table.
The only thing that's "inflexible" is your red-tinted opinion of Hughes...
Ireland... You're kidding right?
SWP... Does he exist in your reality?
There's nothing wrong with demanding hard work on and off the pitch. At City he has the opportunity to have better players who when they work as hard as lesser players can also be creative!
See your friend sir bacon chops' team for an example of that!
CTID
I am the editor of the blog, and the members of mancityblues.com have a wide range of opinion that they want to be expressed through this site. The blog doesn't always agree with member's opinions, but we believe it necessary to widen the debate about the club we all love, and we never edit the responses articles receive for that same reason. I'm sure "news of the blues" wants reply to all responses himself, and will.
Cheers
Clevblue
I would take issue over Stevie Ireland. His form has admittedly dropped off in recent weeks as the demoralisation surrounding him has ground him down too, but basically his form early in the season was a revelation.
We should have been challenging for the top four now. By MH's own admission that is now going to take years. But the owners are the ones who will decide how long we have to put up with the type of dross we saw at home against Middlesbrough. They have to watch it too...
If they decide he goes his feet won't touch
I would argue the points, but with such a blinkered opinion, what's the use.
Just to say Elano has been crap for the last twelev months. A serial sulker who wont work for the team. Sven was warned about his attitude by the Russians and he did manage to get the best out of him for four months, but once he had to play out poition, no real effort.
As for Ireland, you could not be more wrong if you were the King of Wrongland.
Stevie Ireland is a work in progress and thats just what he's doin, progressing at a very nice pace. Not the finished article yet, but getting there. City's best and most consistant player this season with Kompany and Zab.
You will of course have been watching the Brazil v Italy match tonight. Your point again?
Of course - you would have been watching the other match, as Mark Hughes would have been. Says it all...
Of course Elano and Rob impressed it was a friendly.No contact,no pressure
says it all!!!
His passing is generally poor, he doesnt have the vision or the ability of the brazillians. He is creative, but he lacks the intelligance to take that to the next level.
At least 1/3rd of his passing goes adrift, he holds on to the ball too much because he can't pick out a pass when he puts his head down. And he isn't spacially aware, often off side whinging that he doesnt get the ball.
Elano showed last night why he is simply another level. Thats why th elikes of Mourinho rate him.
Sven was warned about him being a whinger, said the guy as shaktah, who have had numerous foreigners that have failed there because of the difficulty of culture, weather and style of football. Castillo for instance. Sven still picked elano, even played him at right back. short memory city fans?
He also started the season extremly well and scored two goals at sunderland, the next game he was dropped. I'm sorry thats poor man managment!!! When Irelans was suspeneded, he was superb , came o n vs stoke and gave us width. Yet he has been dropped again. His performance for brazil was world class agaianst a full strenght world champion italian side who are strong and great defending force. Robinho played the best that he has for some time, Hughes isnt getting the best out of him anymore either.
i have backed my argument up, hughes himslef has said he wanted to replicate what he did at blackburn.
I read somewhere that i had written blackburn were dull. i said they were well organised but overtly too pyhsical, disagree, then disagree with facts!
We started brightly with a side still mainly consisting of the svennis era, funnily enough elano has featured in most of our big wins. We have seen huge decline in form from key players and begs the question why, not just one or two are not performing but most of the squad.
Sven built a side of absorbing the attack and pressing foward with exciting breaks with skill and ability, we dont break any more with the same urgancy despite having these players. Our tactic now that hughes has built his own side for vast amount of cash is to play 6 defensive players and let the attacker punt the ball foward to bellamy.
Both SWP and Ireland final ball leaves much to be desired, but they both have great abiltiy to change tempo and push foawrd, this needs to be utlised in a more productive manner than hughes is achieving, we were incredibly flat vs boro.
we play defensive football away from home and have done all season, look where that has got us. the manager is failing. 1 win away all season is abject at best. We have clever players like elano not being used, Hughs ignored him again int he latest conference, he clearly read this, he isnt going to limit his attackers, he ignored elano.
I'm a city fan, season card holder, i watch the players complete performance, not just havign 2 or 3 succsesful passes a game.
What a pile of narrow minded, ignorant, nonesense that article is.
Wake up and smell the coffee News of the blues. If you are a blue at all.
Sources suggest elano is adgusting? well hughes still doesnt pick him and completley disregarded him in the last press conference.
Ignorant of what? I ve watched every game this season, Elano has been involved with all our big wins but gets dropped. It doesnt make sense. He has failed to get the best out of our strikers, defenders. Now he has spent vast amounts the football has got worse, that doesnt add up.
Bob the blue , zim zimmer and anyone else istead of just slagging the article off, answer with informed opinions and facts, as i have.
Wat you say about stevie ireland just sums up the validity of your article.
a right old Pile of nonesense. Where do people like you get off on such rubbish?